So I’ve spent the best part of this week getting really emotional about the series finale of BBC’s Sherlock. It’s been a good distraction from my exams, which are nearly done now and I don’t think I’ve failed anything so success!! But also it’s made me reflect a lot on Sherlock Holmes and what a tragedy it is that the BBC only had 3 episodes a series, because I was so excited for this and now it’s all over and just.. my emotions.
Cuz Sherlock is by far my favourite incarnation of the consulting detective, although to be fair I have only seen 3, and I have so much respect for the writers and the way they’ve updated and twisted the stories and left in so many little gags for fans of the books and also made it so impossible for us to know what they’re going to do, even when we’ve read the stories and know how Arthur Conan Doyle did it, we know that they’re not gonna make it that simple and it’s gonna be awesome and why why why is it still more than 24 hours away?? Needless to say I’m excited and worried and emotional and my tumblr is just full of reblogs of things like

or

or

or
(Clicking on those images will send to you their creators)
And more but if you’re that interested you can just go look yourself (it’s here)
I’m gonna be really upset when I have to wait forever (maybe literally) for more of this fantastic tv series. It’s just remarkable, the acting, the writing, what they’ve done with the character is phenomenal and they deserve so much credit for it. Also I only found out like 2 weeks ago that Mark Gatiss, one of the co-creators and writers (along with Steven Moffat), is also the actor for Mycroft Holmes and I love his portrayal of him!! Also his tweets are fun!!
To cope with the devastating loss of Sherlock from my tv screen (after only 3 weeks, stupid short, brilliant, series) I decided that it was finally time to complete my collection of Sherlock canon by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. It’s a collection that started in 2009 after I saw and adored the Robert Downey Jr Holmes film. I knew of Sherlock Holmes before obviously, not just for his deerstalker hat and “Elementary, my dear Watson” (Which, incidentally, he never actually said in canon) but mainly because my then favourite character (it’s now under debate) Dr Gregory House was based on Holmes. After watching the film and loving it, especially the relationship between Holmes and Watson, I decided that I’d read some of the books, since it was near my birthday it was easy enough to get Aislinn to buy me some, she hit chapters and bought me 3 collections with plenty of stories in them, although there was some overlap between them. It wasn’t an issue though, since I still haven’t read all of them, two and a half years later. I am getting very close though, with only something like 6 stories out of the 43 she gave me left to go. I’ve also picked up all of the full length novels over the years and read them.
The reason I find it such slow going to read them is mainly down to the oldness of them, the language is a bit different from what’s common now, obviously and I normally have to focus a bit more to follow the story, since it requires more concentration I tend to go for something lighter if I’m reading right before I go to sleep, so Sherlock can get shelved for a while, and it’s only when the mood strikes me that I pick him up again.
Thankfully, I now own every single one ever!! Cuz I went on hunt to find the two collections that I was missing bits of and realised that it would be cheaper to just buy everything in one gigantic volume (seriously it’s huge ) and then I wouldn’t have to go hunting round wondering which book had which stories in it for when I needed and emergency reading of The Empty House just to remind myself that the falls might not be the end. So now I have them all and it’s great and I’m really happy. Also it was only like 9 euro which is awesome

As more Reichenbach preparation, I watched The Final Problem in the Granada tv series, which my dad bought for me on DVD recently. This adaption of the books differs from the more recent ones in that it follows the books pretty closely. It does it very well, but it’s not nearly as exciting, because it’s predictable. Jeremy Brett is a very iconic portrayal of Holmes though, and I’ve enjoyed the episodes I’ve seen.
I’ve yet to delve into the Basil Rathbone films, but I think it’s only a matter of time before I investigate these as well, since Holmes *is* the most portrayed character ever it seems a shame to only see a few adaptions, when I enjoy them so much.
My favourite thing about the modern ones though is that they can go into the exploration or the bromance between Holmes and Watson, something that just didn’t happen in the books. The film captured this wonderfully with little exchanges like
“Watson: Get that out of my face
Holmes: It’s not in your face, it’s in my hand
Watson: Get what’s in your hand *out* of my face”
and also the way it showed the reluctance Holmes had to meet Watson’s fiancé and accept that his best friend, only real friend, was leaving him.
It’s also a dynamic I enjoy in House, although I am a firm House/Wilson shipper and always will be, whereas I’m not so sure about Holmes/Watson.
The BBC series addresses it most directly since it’s set in modern London and gay couples do actually exist openly, so everyone assumes they are one. I think Aislinn’s favourite quote from A Scandal in Belgravia is probably
“Watson: For the record, if anyone out there still cares — I’m not actually gay.”
Martin Freeman’s performance is totally awesome, I love how in the most recent episode, he just can’t be bothered denying it, you can see the emotions flicker on his face and the thought process when someone assumes like
“No.. we’re not actually, oh forget it no one listens to me anyway, may as well just accept their assumptions”
Apparently Freeman is strong in the Falls and will bring people to tears so I’m excited about that, if not about the tears.
With both Martin Freeman and Jude Law (Watson in the film) Watson is played as much more of an equal to Sherlock, not intellectually of course, only Moriarty and Mycroft can really make that claim, but in terms of being a real partner and not just a sidekick. Both Watsons are also brilliant at playing off their Holmes’, It’s awesome.
Speaking of Holmses, I can’t let this post go without mentioning Robert Downey Jr and Benedict Cumberbatch more. They both do fantastic jobs of bringing the detective to life. They make him snappy and fantastic and hilarious and they’re both really hot which helps and they’re just insane!!
Just a few more things for me to flail wildly about before I give up and just accept that I will never adequately express my love for these things with words…
1) Andrew Scott as Moriarty. This man is Moriarty as he’s never been done before, rather than the old, sedate maths professor with the fantastic brain who is secretly dealing with all his criminal stuff on the side, this is a young, manic, insane Moriarty who’s frightening and unpredictable (“Sorry boys, I’m *so* changeable !”) and intense and when he says it, you really do believe that he will “burn the HEART out of you” or “make you into shoes”
His big scene so far was amazing, heart in the mouth confrontation where he shows that he’s not just frustrated by Sherlock, but fascinated by him as well and loves messing with him
“Sherlock Holmes: What if I were to just shoot you now? Right now?
Jim Moriarty: Well, then you could cherish the look of surprise on my face. Because I’d be surprised, Sherlock, really I would, and just a little bit… disappointed. And of course, you wouldn’t be able to cherish it for very long. “
The fact that he’d be disappointed, shows that he’s expecting something from Sherlock, that he respects him.. in a weird way.
It’s creepy and unpredictable and it didn’t fade from anybody’s mind in the year and a half before the cliffhanger in it was resolved. Whatever The writers have done with the Falls, this guy is definitely the actor to do it justice.
2 Is the use of text in the show. For phone screens and blog posts to be shown to the audience, but mainly when Sherlock is doing his thing, we get a little glimpse into his thought process, all of the tiny flashes that he’s picking up while the rest of the room has gotten about as far as “okay, it’s a man” It’s fantastic and one of the cleverest things about the series, IMO. Cuz when he explains it then, you saw him noticing, rather than him just reeling off “I saw this and it meant that” which is the best that a book can do.
It’s just by far the best TV show I’ve seen in a very long time. And I feel bad for the film, because they did this new and exciting adaption of the stories, and then a year later the TV show came along and did an even newer even more exciting version, which, in my head at any rate, kind of blew theirs out of the water.
Even when I went to see the second film there before Christmas I was disappointed, because it wasn’t as good as the first and because I didn’t have as much admiration for the writers. Not that I’m trying to be insulting, I really do love what they’ve done and I have a huge amount of respect for the work that they, along with everyone else involved in it, have put into the film which I did enjoy a whole lot. it’s just that as soon as Mycroft (played by the awesome Stephen Fry, something else that would have been more awesome if not for how much I love Mark Gatiss) mentioned Reichenbach early in the film, I knew how it was gonna play out in the end, even if the plot to get to that point was completely different. Whereas in Sherlock I’ve known for months that it was going to be Reichenbach tomorrow, and I’m still completely guessing.
If I let this rest for a few minutes and then came back I’m sure I’d have thought of 500 other little details that I could mention and praise about the show, but I would definitely advise anyone to watch it. It’s fantastic if you’ve read the books like I have, or if you haven’t like Aislinn, or if you’ve seen lots of other Holmes adaptions, like my dad. It’s just amazing.
Also if you know a Sherlock fan, offer them plenty of emotional support tomorrow, and don’t even dream of interrupting them after 9.00!!
I might post again after tomorrow with my views on the finale, but it’s more likely that I’ll be in deep mourning and incapable of stringing a sentence together, or indeed successfully completing my calculus exam on Monday morning. I don’t think “All Sherlocked out” is a valid excuse though… pity.And what other way could I possibly leave this than
“Sorry, got to dash. I think I left my riding crop in the mortuary.”

